Real EstateNovember 19, 2026·2d ago

    Mamdani Administration Files Fraud Lawsuit Against NYC Landlords Under False Claims Act

    The administration of Mayor Zohran Mamdani is deploying a novel legal strategy to penalize property owners who fail to address hazardous building violations. As reported by Bisnow, the city filed a lawsuit in Bronx County Supreme Court against Barry Singer and Daniel Caller, marking the first time a 2005 fraud law has been used for housing enforcement.

    Industry Pulse News Desk · Edited by Maksym Lobodiuk
    Mamdani Administration Files Fraud Lawsuit Against NYC Landlords Under False Claims Act

    Context from Industry Pulse

    The Mamdani administration is expanding its toolkit for housing enforcement as traditional methods have struggled to compel repairs or secure payment from persistent violators. By reclassifying unpaid repair debts and ignored judgments as fraud under the False Claims Act, the city is shifting from administrative penalties to high-stakes litigation. This move targets the use of corporate shells to avoid personal liability, a common frustration for municipal regulators. While the legal community monitors this first-of-its-kind application of a two-decade-old law, the strategy aligns with broader executive efforts to empower renters through public hearings and organizational support, specifically focusing on owners with lengthy histories of documented neglect across multiple boroughs.

    "When the same old tools fail to deliver results, we will use new strategies to hold noncompliant landlords accountable and win justice for tenants."

    The legal action centers on allegations that the landlords engaged in fraud by evading financial obligations to the city. According to Bisnow, the defendants owe approximately 1.1 million dollars for emergency repairs performed by municipal agencies at properties with severe safety hazards. The city argues that the owners used limited liability companies to shield themselves from these debts while allowing conditions to deteriorate over at least three years.

    The lawsuit targets 11 properties located in the Bronx and Brooklyn. City attorneys allege that the buildings suffer from dangerous structural issues, including fire escapes damaged by rust, significant cracks, and building facades that are at risk of collapsing. Other reported violations involve unpermitted electrical work and failures to manage vermin or pest infestations. Bisnow reports that Barry Singer has been a frequent fixture on the Public Advocate Office list of the city's worst landlords.

    By invoking the False Claims Act, the city is seeking significantly higher financial penalties than traditional housing court judgments allow. Under this law, the municipality can claim triple damages for the 1.06 million dollars spent on city-led repairs, totaling more than 3 million dollars. Additionally, the suit alleges violations of nuisance abatement laws, which could bring the total liability for the defendants to more than 10 million dollars when including various unpaid legal judgments.

    This litigation was developed in partnership with the Housing Rights Initiative and represents a shift in how the current administration handles noncompliant property owners. Bisnow notes that the mayor has made addressing substandard housing a priority during his first year, including efforts to encourage the formation of tenant unions. If this application of the False Claims Act is successful, it may provide a new template for New York City to recoup public funds spent on private building maintenance.

    The Industry Pulse Bottom Line

    If the city successfully applies the False Claims Act to housing violations, it could fundamentally change the risk-reward calculus for negligent landlords by enabling multi-million dollar triple-damage judgments.